Skip The Critics
What real people actually think. Tomatoes are for critics...
Every night we scour social media, read the real comments, by the real audience and show you exactly what they think. No paid shills here.
All films
In the Hand of Dante poster
Jun 12, 2026

In the Hand of Dante

Poorly received
Reactions
184
Score confidence
high
Score trend
Box office
Not reported yet
41
Score

The film

A Vatican priest discovers Dante's original Divine Comedy manuscript. When asked to authenticate it, writer Nick Tosches steals it, while a parallel story follows Dante's quest to create his masterpiece.

The Cast
Oscar Isaac
Nick / Dante
Gal Gadot
Giulietta / Gemma
Gerard Butler
Louie / Pope Bonifacio
John Malkovich
Joe Black
Louis Cancelmi
Lefty / Guido Novello Da Polenta
Sabrina Impacciatore
Dr. Susanna Pulice
Franco Nero
Don Lecco (86)

The real review

This is a divisive mess that most people walked away from frustrated. The split is between those who appreciate Julian Schnabel's bold visual style and the high-concept premise about Oscar Isaac stealing Dante's manuscript, and the much larger group who find the story a pretentious, incomprehensible slog. The pacing is universally slammed as glacial, and the dual-narrative structure loses almost everyone. A few bright spots pop up — Gerard Butler gets some praise for his role, and the visuals are striking — but they're not enough to salvage the experience for most.

Most praised
Humor
Visuals
Acting
Originality
Most faulted
Pacing
Story
Most divisive

Sentiment split

25% positive
32% mixed
43% negative

By aspect

story13
originality61
acting73
visuals81
pacing0
humor100

How opinion moved

41
Jul 10
41
Jul 10

Buzz

Jun 2791 reactions over two weeksJul 10

How much people are talking about this film — reactions counted per day they were posted.

Names & topics that came up

Julian Schnabelperson40× · 25%+Oscar Isaacperson37× · 22%+Gerard Butlerperson29× · 48%+Gal Gadotperson18× · 33%+John Malkovichperson10× · 20%+Dantecharacter5× · 20%+Nick Toschesperson4× · 50%+Al Pacinoperson3× · 67%+Schnabelperson2× · 0%+Franco Neroperson2× · 100%+Benjamin Clementineperson2× · 100%+Roman Vasyanovperson2× · 50%+

Where the signal came from

Social Media
184

We show volume and platform mix, not posts. No comment text is stored or displayed — every figure above is analysis output. Social media data only, for now.