People have a morbid fascination with this true crime staple, but it's a polarizing watch. While many find its premise of profiling women accused of murder endlessly compelling, nearly as many are worn out by its formulaic storytelling and repetitive structure. The show's concept clearly hooks a large part of its audience, even as others feel the stories and visuals have become predictable over its many seasons. A few viewers even joke about the show's title becoming a meme, but the core draw remains the unsettling question of why these seemingly ordinary lives turn deadly.
Synthesized from 118 real reactionshigh confidence