GamesThick as Thieves
Thick as Thieves poster
Released May 20, 2026

Thick as Thieves

2026 · T · Simulator, Indie
OtherSide Entertainment · PC · PS5 · Xbox Series X|S

Enter the shadows in this introduction to Thick as Thieves. In the shadow-draped streets of Kilcairn, fortune favours the bold. As a member of the Thieves' Guild, you'll undertake daring heists to claim precious heirlooms and uncover arcane secrets hidden within this alternate-history 1910s Scottish city, where magic and early technology have begun to collide. Whether working alone or playing online co-op, only the most cunning will seize their fortune in Thick as Thieves!

Real Score
58
Divisive
from 715 reactions
very high confidence
47% positive22% mixed31% negative
→ SteadyTrend
3Platforms

What people are saying

Updated nightly
The Real Review

Reactions to Thick as Thieves are split, with the core concept of magic and stealth heists in an alternate 1910s Scotland getting overshadowed by major execution problems. The online co-op and stealth mechanics are highlights for those who can play, but widespread performance issues, especially on PC and Xbox, are tanking the experience. Many are frustrated with the launch state, feeling the $40 price isn't justified by the current buggy, unstable gameplay. It's a rough heist where the technical jank is the real thing to steal.

Synthesized from 715 real reactions · very high confidenceGraphicsMultiplayerGameplayValueStoryPerformanceDifficulty

Sentiment split

Every qualifying reaction, weighted.

47%positive
  • Positive47%
  • Mixed22%
  • Negative31%

By aspect

What people scored, piece by piece.

graphics69
multiplayer67
gameplay58
value50
story46
difficulty39
performance17

How opinion moved

The Real Score, night by night.

565860Sep 2729Oct 1355858

Buzz

19 reactions over two weeks, counted by the day they were posted.

024Sep 19: 3 reactionsSep 19Sep 20: 0 reactionsSep 21: 2 reactions21Sep 22: 0 reactionsSep 23: 1 reaction23Sep 24: 0 reactionsSep 25: 1 reaction25Sep 26: 1 reactionSep 27: 1 reaction27Sep 28: 0 reactionsSep 29: 0 reactions29Sep 30: 0 reactionsOct 1: 0 reactions1Oct 2: 1 reaction2

Where the signal came from

Volume and platform mix only.

Social Media423
Steam292

Every figure on this page is analysis output from public posts and reviews.

We show volume and platform mix, not posts. No comment text is stored or displayed.

Names and topics that came up

Mentions across all reactions, with the share that were positive. Anything mentioned fewer than twice never shapes the review.

OtherSide Entertainmentdeveloper345×10%+
Thick as Thievesfeature49×51%+
Steamplatform48×2%+
PCplatform47×0%+
Twitchplatform37×0%+
Warren Spectordeveloper32×44%+
Xbox Series X|Splatform24×0%+
Thieves' Guildfeature24×17%+
co-opfeature23×78%+
mapsfeature13×31%+
YouTubeplatform12×0%+
devsdeveloper10×80%+
Thick as Thievescharacter10×40%+
stealthfeature7×71%+
Thick as Thievesdeveloper7×43%+

Trailer and screenshots

More like this

All games →