What real people actually think. Tomatoes are for critics...

Every night we scour social media, read the real comments, by the real audience, and show you exactly what they think. No paid shills here.

May 20, 2026

Thick as Thieves

Divisive

Reactions

679

Score confidence

very high

Score trend

↑

Platforms

PC · PS5 · Xbox Series X|S

Age rating

Score

The game

Enter the shadows in this introduction to Thick as Thieves. In the shadow-draped streets of Kilcairn, fortune favours the bold. As a member of the Thieves' Guild, you'll undertake daring heists to claim precious heirlooms and uncover arcane secrets hidden within this alternate-history 1910s Scottish city, where magic and early technology have begun to collide. Whether working alone or playing online co-op, only the most cunning will seize their fortune in Thick as Thieves!

Developer

OtherSide Entertainment

Platforms

PC · PS5 · Xbox Series X|S

Screenshots

The Real Review

The co-op is a bright spot in an otherwise disappointing early look at Thick as Thieves. People digging into the alternate-history Scottish heists find the gameplay a bit middling and the story forgettable, but the biggest complaints are technical. Performance is a major letdown across PC and consoles, with crashes and bugs getting constant mention. The overall reception is lukewarm, with a vocal majority frustrated by the state of the game and its perceived value.

Synthesized from 679 real reactionsvery high confidence

PraisedMultiplayer · Graphics

FaultedPerformance · Difficulty · Story

DivisiveGameplay · Value

Sentiment split

48% positive

22% mixed

29% negative

By aspect

gameplay59

value52

multiplayer68

performance16

difficulty40

graphics67

story43

How opinion moved

Aug 15

Buzz

Aug 1039 reactions over two weeksAug 23

How much people are talking about this game: reactions counted per day they were posted.

Names & topics that came up

OtherSide Entertainmentdeveloper332× · 9%+Thick as Thievesfeature49× · 51%+Steamplatform47× · 0%+PCplatform47× · 0%+Twitchplatform37× · 0%+Warren Spectordeveloper31× · 45%+Xbox Series X|Splatform24× · 0%+Thieves' Guildfeature24× · 17%+co-opfeature23× · 78%+YouTubeplatform12× · 0%+mapsfeature12× · 33%+devsdeveloper10× · 80%+Thick as Thievescharacter10× · 40%+Thick as Thievesplatform7× · 14%+Thick as Thievesdeveloper7× · 43%+

Where the signal came from

Social Media

415

Steam

264

We show volume and platform mix, not posts. No comment text is stored or displayed. Every figure above is analysis output from public posts and reviews.