Signal One gets a shrug overall, with the core premise of tech geniuses investigating alien artifacts in the Caribbean feeling deeply familiar to many. The debate is over whether that's a comfortable or a boring retread, and the acting rarely sways opinions, Dennis Quaid and David Thewlis don't win people over, while Isabelle Fuhrman gets more love in her role as scientist Annika. Ultimately, the stunning, high-score visuals can't compensate for what's widely seen as a forgettable story.
Synthesized from 54 real reactionshigh confidence
