Awards seasonIf players picked The Game Awards 2026 nominees
The Game Awards announced its nominees on Tuesday. A jury of critics and outlets picked them, and Grand Theft Auto VI leads with eight before anyone has played it. So we asked a different question: who would be nominated if the only vote that counted was what players actually say about the year's games?
We measure what people say about games in public social media conversations and Steam reviews, classified and scored nightly, with the sample size and confidence beside every number. For this piece we took every game on our board released in the year up to the show's November 20 cutoff and rebuilt all 30 categories from that data.
A ballot of the highest scores alone turns into a list of small games most people haven't heard of: players are often warmest about the little ones they found themselves. So every category we can measure has two crowd ballots, one for studio games and one for indies, with The Game Awards' own nominees beside them and our number for each. Indie is IGDB's indie tag, checked by hand where it missed an independent studio.
Three limits are worth knowing before you read. Our games board only reaches back to spring 2026, so most games released between November 2025 and March 2026 aren't on it, and that includes several of the show's nominees. Ten categories, from esports to accessibility, measure things our data doesn't see, and they say so. And this is what people who post about games think, not a representative sample of every player.
Game of the Year
Game of the Year
- 1Onimusha: Way of the Sword9,378 reactions88
- 2Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy3,529 reactions87
- 3Tomodachi Life: Living the Dream3,359 reactions85
- 4Pragmata7,188 reactions83
- 5Clive Barker's Hellraiser: Revival5,321 reactions83
- 1The Mermaid Mask3,465 reactions97
- 2Well Dweller3,061 reactions94
- 3Iron Nest: Heavy Turret Simulator4,357 reactions92
- 4Dead as Disco3,418 reactions92
- 5Denshattack!9,031 reactions91
- TGAControl Resonant20,820 reactions81
- TGA007 First Light7,729 reactions77
- TGAThe Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time9,732 reactions77
- TGAResident Evil Requiem865 reactions72
- TGAPhantom Blade Zero3,750 reactions69
- TGAGrand Theft Auto VIHype Score 60 from 50,823 · out Nov 19--
Audience score of every eligible game with at least 3,000 reactions.
None of the show's six makes either crowd ballot. Control Resonant comes closest at 81 from 20,820 reactions, two points behind the crowd's fifth studio pick. Grand Theft Auto VI can't be scored until it comes out on Thursday; its Hype Score is 60 from 50,823 reactions, cooler than Ocarina of Time's 72 or Control Resonant's 79 before they launched.
The crowd's studio ballot is led by Capcom's Onimusha: Way of the Sword at 88 from 9,378 reactions, which the show nominated only for Best Action Game. Behind it, Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy (87), Tomodachi Life: Living the Dream (85) and Clive Barker's Hellraiser: Revival (83) didn't get a single nomination in any category. On the indie side, The Mermaid Mask is the highest-scoring game of the year on our board, 97 from 3,465 reactions, and it wasn't nominated either.
The craft awards
For the craft categories we score only what people say about that one thing: how a game plays, its story, how it looks, its music and its sound. A game can score 75 overall and 95 on its art, and these ballots catch that.
Best Game Direction
- 1Onimusha: Way of the Sword5,451 mentions91
- 2Trails in the Sky 2nd Chapter489 mentions91
- 3LEGO Batman: Legacy of the Dark Knight997 mentions87
- 4Ace Combat 8: Wings of Theve5,009 mentions86
- 5Star Wars Zero Company6,416 mentions86
- 1Well Dweller1,732 mentions96
- 2The Mermaid Mask1,487 mentions94
- 3Dead as Disco1,952 mentions94
- 4Denshattack!4,159 mentions93
- 5Big Walk15,408 mentions92
- TGAPragmata2,346 mentions86
- TGAPhantom Blade Zero862 mentions82
- TGAResident Evil Requiem71 mentions80
- TGAControl Resonant7,714 mentions77
- TGAGrand Theft Auto VIHype Score 60 from 50,823 · out Nov 19--
Scored only on what people say about the way it plays, out of 100, among games with 2,000+ reactions and at least 150 mentions of it.
Best Narrative
- 1Trails in the Sky 2nd Chapter574 mentions93
- 2The Blood of Dawnwalker4,646 mentions90
- 3Star Wars Zero Company4,107 mentions88
- 4Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 42,486 mentions87
- 5Clive Barker's Hellraiser: Revival2,001 mentions85
- 1The Mermaid Mask1,929 mentions98
- 2Well Dweller863 mentions95
- 3Big Walk3,212 mentions93
- 4Endacopia1,600 mentions92
- 5Denshattack!816 mentions84
- TGAThe Blood of Dawnwalker4,646 mentions90
- TGA007 First Light2,355 mentions82
- TGAControl Resonant5,533 mentions82
- TGAResident Evil Requiem91 mentions65
- TGAGrand Theft Auto VIHype Score 60 from 50,823 · out Nov 19--
Scored only on what people say about the story, out of 100, among games with 2,000+ reactions and at least 60 mentions of it.
Story is where the crowd and the jury overlap. The Blood of Dawnwalker is on both lists, and on ours it scores 90 on story from 4,646 mentions, well above its overall 82. Trails in the Sky 2nd Chapter tops the studio ballot at 93 and gets no Narrative nod from the show.
Best Art Direction
- 1Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy1,266 mentions96
- 2Trails in the Sky 2nd Chapter204 mentions96
- 3Saros162 mentions94
- 4Onimusha: Way of the Sword1,670 mentions93
- 5Clive Barker's Hellraiser: Revival1,453 mentions93
- 1The Mermaid Mask1,134 mentions99
- 2Well Dweller859 mentions98
- 3Orbitals455 mentions98
- 4Endacopia850 mentions97
- 5Silver Pines785 mentions97
- TGAMouse: P.I. For Hire809 mentions96
- TGAControl Resonant2,722 mentions92
- TGAThe Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time895 mentions91
- TGAPhantom Blade Zero206 mentions86
- TGAGrand Theft Auto VIHype Score 60 from 50,823 · out Nov 19--
Scored only on what people say about the look, out of 100, among games with 2,000+ reactions and at least 120 mentions of it.
Best Score and Music
- 1Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy125 mentions100
- 2Final Fantasy Resonance40 mentions98
- 3Ace Combat 8: Wings of Theve1,215 mentions95
- 4Control Resonant351 mentions89
- 5The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time59 mentions85
- 1Silver Pines168 mentions98
- 2The Mermaid Mask66 mentions98
- 3Dead as Disco142 mentions98
- 4Denshattack!626 mentions97
- 5Endacopia133 mentions96
- TGAAce Combat 8: Wings of Theve1,215 mentions95
- TGAThe Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time59 mentions85
- TGAPhantom Blade Zero31 mentions84
- TGAMixtape249 mentions79
- TGAGrand Theft Auto VIHype Score 60 from 50,823 · out Nov 19--
Share of mentions of a game's music or soundtrack that are positive, with at least 40 mentions.
Music is the one craft category where the show's picks hold up. Ace Combat 8's soundtrack is talked about positively 95% of the time across 1,215 mentions, more than any other game's music, and Ocarina of Time's orchestral rework makes both lists too.
Best Audio Design
- 1Star Wars: Galactic Racer106 mentions100
- 2Silent Hill: Townfall114 mentions95
- 1Iron Nest: Heavy Turret Simulator53 mentions100
- TGAStar Wars: Galactic Racer106 mentions100
- TGAAce Combat 8: Wings of Thevetoo few mentions · overall 80 from 13,909--
- TGAControl Resonanttoo few mentions · overall 81 from 20,820--
- TGAGrand Theft Auto VIHype Score 60 from 50,823 · out Nov 19--
- TGAResident Evil Requiemtoo few mentions · overall 72 from 865--
Share of mentions of a game's sound design that are positive. People rarely talk about sound design by name, so only three games clear the floor of eight mentions.
Best Performance
- 1Doug BradleyClive Barker's Hellraiser: Revival · 61 mentions98
- 2MusashiOnimusha: Way of the Sword · 490 mentions88
- 3CenobitesClive Barker's Hellraiser: Revival · 172 mentions86
- 4EstelleTrails in the Sky 2nd Chapter · 160 mentions82
- 5HawksStar Wars Zero Company · 183 mentions79
- TGAPatrick GibsonJames Bond · 1,292 mentions74
- TGALiam McIntyreWolverine · 411 mentions56
- TGAAngela Sant'AlbanoGrace Ashcroft · 69 mentions54
- TGARahul KohliArjun Devraj · 62 mentions42
- TGAManni L. PerezLucia Caminos · Grand Theft Auto VI · not out yet--
We can't score an actor's craft, so this ranks the characters and people players speak most warmly about: share of positive mentions, with at least 25 mentions.
We can't score acting, so this card ranks the characters and people players speak most warmly about. Doug Bradley, the original films' Pinhead, back for Hellraiser: Revival, is mentioned positively 98% of the time. Of the show's nominees, Patrick Gibson's James Bond does best at 74 across 1,292 mentions; Wolverine sits at 56 from 411, so only a little over half of what players say about him is warm.
Innovation in Accessibility
Outside our data- TGARhythm Heaven Groove3,589 reactions79
- TGAAssassin's Creed Black Flag Resynced9,985 reactions77
- TGAMarvel's Wolverine4,164 reactions68
- TGAGears of War: E-Day14,633 reactions65
- TGAForza Horizon 69,801 reactions59
Accessibility rarely comes up in the reactions we score, so we can't rank it. Here is how the nominees score overall.
Indies and impact
Best Independent Game
- 1The Mermaid Mask3,465 reactions97
- 2Well Dweller3,061 reactions94
- 3Iron Nest: Heavy Turret Simulator4,357 reactions92
- 4Dead as Disco3,418 reactions92
- 5Denshattack!9,031 reactions91
- TGADenshattack9,031 reactions91
- TGABig Walk33,357 reactions89
- TGAMina the Hollower6,274 reactions79
- TGACairnnot on our board--
- TGAMewgenicsnot on our board--
Audience score of independent games with 2,000+ reactions.
The show's indie field and ours share one game, Denshattack!, which scores 91 from 9,031 reactions and turns up on seven of the crowd's ballots, more than any other game along with Well Dweller. Big Walk, the show's most nominated indie, scores 89 from 33,357 reactions, the biggest conversation of any eligible game on our board.
Best Debut Indie Game
Partly measured- TGADressmaker23,250 reactions91
- TGASilver Pines4,127 reactions84
- TGAOrbitals2,323 reactions80
- TGAReplaced1,654 reactions78
- TGAEsoteric Ebbnot on our board--
Our data can't tell a studio's first game from its fifth, so there is no crowd ballot here. Four of the five nominees are on our board.
Games for Impact
Outside our data- TGALily's World XD1,350 reactions94
- TGABig Walk33,357 reactions89
- TGAForever Ago506 reactions83
- TGAMixtape1,840 reactions74
- TGACairnnot on our board--
- TGALife is Strange: Reunionnot on our board--
Impact is about a game's message, which we don't measure. Here is how the nominees score overall.
The genre awards
Genres come from IGDB, so a game can sit in more than one, as it does on the show's lists. Some genres are thin on our board: only four fighting games and six sports or racing games have enough reactions to rank, which is why the crowd and the show overlap so much there.
Best Action Game
- 1Onimusha: Way of the Sword9,378 reactions88
- 2Pragmata7,188 reactions83
- 3Control Resonant20,820 reactions81
- 4007 First Light7,729 reactions77
- 5Saros2,505 reactions76
- 1Dead as Disco3,418 reactions92
- 2Twisted Tower2,020 reactions85
- 3Mouse: P.I. For Hire3,006 reactions83
- TGAOnimusha: Way of the Sword9,378 reactions88
- TGAAce Combat 8: Wings of Theve13,909 reactions80
- TGASaros2,505 reactions76
- TGAPhantom Blade Zero3,750 reactions69
- TGAGears of War: E-Day14,633 reactions65
Shooters, hack and slash and brawlers by IGDB genre, 2,000+ reactions.
Best Action/Adventure Game
- 1Pragmata7,188 reactions83
- 2007 First Light7,729 reactions77
- 3The Sinking City 22,211 reactions76
- 4Splatoon Raiders12,303 reactions73
- 5Marvel's Wolverine4,164 reactions68
- 1Denshattack!9,031 reactions91
- 2Big Walk33,357 reactions89
- 3Twisted Tower2,020 reactions85
- 4Mouse: P.I. For Hire3,006 reactions83
- 5Orbitals2,323 reactions80
- TGAPragmata7,188 reactions83
- TGAControl Resonant20,820 reactions81
- TGA007 First Light7,729 reactions77
- TGAThe Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time9,732 reactions77
- TGAResident Evil Requiem865 reactions72
- TGAGrand Theft Auto VIHype Score 60 from 50,823 · out Nov 19--
Adventure games with shooting, combat or platforming by IGDB genre, 2,000+ reactions.
Best Role-Playing Game
- 1Onimusha: Way of the Sword9,378 reactions88
- 2Trails in the Sky 2nd Chapter2,164 reactions86
- 3The Blood of Dawnwalker10,886 reactions82
- 4Control Resonant20,820 reactions81
- 5Fire Emblem: Fortune's Weave10,566 reactions77
- 1Well Dweller3,061 reactions94
- 2Duskfade2,234 reactions86
- 3Moonlight Peaks4,694 reactions84
- 4Mina the Hollower6,274 reactions79
- 5Queen's Domain4,980 reactions77
- TGATrails in the Sky 2nd Chapter2,164 reactions86
- TGAThe Blood of Dawnwalker10,886 reactions82
- TGAFire Emblem: Fortune's Weave10,566 reactions77
- TGAFinal Fantasy Resonance4,751 reactions75
- TGAMonster Hunter Stories 3: Twisted Reflectionnot on our board--
Role-playing games by IGDB genre, 2,000+ reactions.
Best Sim/Strategy Game
- 1Tomodachi Life: Living the Dream3,359 reactions85
- 2Star Wars Zero Company10,846 reactions81
- 3Ace Combat 8: Wings of Theve13,909 reactions80
- 4Fire Emblem: Fortune's Weave10,566 reactions77
- 5Active Matter2,567 reactions72
- 1Iron Nest: Heavy Turret Simulator4,357 reactions92
- 2ReStory: Chill Electronics Repairs5,210 reactions90
- 3How to Fish7,188 reactions89
- 4Over the Hill2,484 reactions88
- 5Librarian: Tidy Up the Arcane Library!4,819 reactions87
- TGAStar Wars Zero Company10,846 reactions81
- TGAPlanet Zoo 24,299 reactions57
- TGAMewgenicsnot on our board--
- TGAPokémon Pokopianot on our board--
- TGASlay the Spire IInot on our board--
Simulation, strategy and tactics games by IGDB genre, 2,000+ reactions.
Best Fighting Game
- 1Avatar Legends: The Fighting Game2,504 reactions77
- 2Invincible Vs.1,490 reactions64
- 3Marvel Tokon: Fighting Souls5,558 reactions52
- 1Dead as Disco3,418 reactions92
- TGAAvatar Legends: The Fighting Game2,504 reactions77
- TGAInvincible VS1,490 reactions64
- TGAMarvel Tōkon: Fighting Souls5,558 reactions52
- TGA2XKOnot on our board--
- TGAMy Hero Academia: All's Justicenot on our board--
Fighting games by IGDB genre, 1,000+ reactions. Only four qualify.
Best Family Game
- 1Tomodachi Life: Living the Dream3,359 reactions85
- 2LEGO Batman: Legacy of the Dark Knight2,420 reactions84
- 3Rhythm Heaven Groove3,589 reactions79
- 4Star Wars: Galactic Racer9,808 reactions78
- 5Subnautica 25,300 reactions78
- 1Big Walk33,357 reactions89
- 2Duskfade2,234 reactions86
- 3Order of the Sinking Star2,050 reactions86
- 4Orbitals2,323 reactions80
- 5Mina the Hollower6,274 reactions79
- TGABig Walk33,357 reactions89
- TGALego Batman: Legacy of the Dark Knight2,420 reactions84
- TGAYoshi and the Mysterious Book1,247 reactions74
- TGANintendo Switch Sports Resort985 reactions70
- TGAPokémon Pokopianot on our board--
Games rated E or E10+ (or PEGI 3 or 7), 2,000+ reactions.
Best Sports/Racing Game
- 1Star Wars: Galactic Racer9,808 reactions78
- 2Forza Horizon 69,801 reactions59
- 3NBA 2K272,495 reactions42
- 4EA Sports FC 273,765 reactions38
- 1Denshattack!9,031 reactions91
- 2Over the Hill2,484 reactions88
- TGAStar Wars: Galactic Racer9,808 reactions78
- TGANintendo Switch Sports Resort985 reactions70
- TGAForza Horizon 69,801 reactions59
- TGAEA Sports FC 273,765 reactions38
- TGAScreamernot on our board--
Sports and racing games by IGDB genre, 1,000+ reactions.
Sports and racing has the widest gap between a nominee and its audience. EA Sports FC 27 is on the show's list with a score of 38 from 3,765 reactions, the lowest of any nominee on our board, and Forza Horizon 6 sits at 59 from 9,801. Players would have put Denshattack! (91) and Over the Hill (88) there instead.
Best VR/AR Game
Outside our data- TGAForefrontnot on our board--
- TGAInto the Radius 2not on our board--
- TGALittle Nightmares VR: Altered Echoesnot on our board--
- TGATeenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Empire Citynot on our board--
- TGAThief VR: Legacy of Shadownot on our board--
We don't track headset games yet, so none of the five nominees are on our board.
Best Mobile Game
- 1NTE: Neverness to Everness3,560 reactions74
- 2Aniimo11,941 reactions70
- 1Servant of the Lake1,101 reactions93
- 2Moonlight Peaks4,694 reactions84
- 3Vampire Crawlers: The Turbo Wildcard from Vampire Survivors1,122 reactions84
- TGAArknights Endfieldnot on our board--
- TGAMonster Hunter Outlandersnot on our board--
- TGANeverness to Evernessnot on our board--
- TGAPokémon Championsnot on our board--
- TGAWhere Winds Meetnot on our board--
Games that are also on phones, 1,000+ reactions. We don't track phone-only games, so none of the show's nominees are on our board.
Online and ongoing
Best Multiplayer
- 1Trails in the Sky 2nd Chapter46 mentions91
- 2Rhythm Heaven Groove97 mentions87
- 3Subnautica 2681 mentions86
- 4Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy131 mentions84
- 5Control Resonant275 mentions82
- 1Endacopia102 mentions98
- 2Well Dweller154 mentions98
- 3Far Far West709 mentions93
- 4How to Fish1,478 mentions92
- 5Big Walk9,652 mentions91
- TGABig Walk9,652 mentions91
- TGAOrbitals275 mentions85
- TGAMeccha Chameleon2,732 mentions78
- TGACall of Duty: Modern Warfare 4901 mentions59
- TGAGears of War: E-Day2,646 mentions53
- TGAMarathonnot on our board--
Scored only on what people say about playing together, with at least 40 mentions.
Playing together is where big studio shooters struggle with this crowd. Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4 scores 59 on multiplayer from 901 mentions and Gears of War: E-Day 53 from 2,646, while Big Walk, on both lists, scores 91 from 9,652.
Best Ongoing Game
- 1Dressmakerout since 2025 · 23,250 reactions91
- 2Waterpark Simulatorout since 2025 · 3,499 reactions90
- 3Fields of Mistriaout since 2024 · 19,811 reactions87
- 4Welcome to Elderfieldout since 2024 · 3,242 reactions87
- 5Palworldout since 2024 · 41,008 reactions84
- TGAArc Raidersnot on our board--
- TGAFinal Fantasy XIVnot on our board--
- TGAFortnitenot on our board--
- TGANo Man's Skynot on our board--
- TGAThe Witcher III: Wild Huntwe track the 2026 Remastered edition, not this one--
Games released before the eligibility window that people are still talking about this month, 3,000+ reactions.
Best Community Support
Outside our data- TGACrimson Desertnot on our board--
- TGAHelldivers IInot on our board--
- TGANo Man's Skynot on our board--
- TGAThe Witcher III: Wild Huntwe track only the 2026 Remastered edition--
- TGAWarframenot on our board--
Community support is about how a studio treats its players over time, which our scores don't isolate. None of the nominees are on our board in their original form.
Best User Creation
Outside our data- A Dream of Silence: Revamped (Baldur's Gate 3)
- Create Aeronautics (Minecraft)
- Nopixel V (Grand Theft Auto Online)
- Star Wars Droid Tycoon (Fortnite)
- TTK Testing (Roblox)
New this year, for things players built. We score released games, not mods and maps.
On screen, and what's next
Best Adaptation
- 1Cyberpunk: Edgerunners (Season 2)2,572 reactions78
- 2Resident Evil16,029 reactions76
- 3Street Fighter6,532 reactions64
- 4Mortal Kombat II1,313 reactions64
- TGACyberpunk: Edgerunners (Season 2)2,572 reactions78
- TGAResident Evil16,029 reactions76
- TGAMortal Kombat II1,313 reactions64
- TGAFallout (Season 2)not on our board--
- TGAThe Super Mario Galaxy Movienot on our board--
We score films and shows too. These are the game adaptations on our board from this year.
Most Anticipated Game
Outside our data- Fable
- Final Fantasy VII Revelation
- God of War Laufey
- Resident Evil Veronica
- The Witcher IV
Our Hype Score only starts in the weeks before a game comes out, and none of these five has a release date that close.
Esports and creators
Best Esports Game
Outside our data- Counter-Strike 2
- Dota 2
- League of Legends
- Mobile Legends: Bang Bang
- Valorant
Long-running competitive games sit outside our release-year board.
Best Esports Athlete
Outside our data- Chovy
- donk
- erde
- Yatoro
- ZywOo
We score games, films and shows, not players.
Best Esports Team
Outside our data- Gen.G (League of Legends)
- Loud (Valorant)
- Team Falcons (Counter-Strike 2)
- Team Falcons (Rocket League)
- Team Spirit (Dota 2)
- Team Vitality (Counter-Strike 2)
We score games, films and shows, not teams.
Content Creator of the Year
Outside our data- CDawg
- Cellbit
- IShowSpeed
- lilsimsie
- ohnePixel
We score games, films and shows, not creators.
What the crowd's ballot says
Across the 19 categories we can measure, 25 of the show's 93 nominees also appear on the crowd's ballots. Most of that agreement comes from small genres with few games to choose from. In the categories that draw the most attention, Game of the Year, Game Direction and Art Direction, the overlap is none.
That isn't the jury being wrong. Critics judge craft and ambition, often before release and with the whole year in view, and our board only covers part of that year. But it does say something about what players reward, and how far it can sit from what wins trophies. The 42 game nominees we can score average 76. The crowd's studio Game of the Year ballot averages 85, and its indie ballot 93.
The Game Awards are on December 10. We'll keep scoring every one of these games every night, and Grand Theft Auto VI gets its first Real Score after Thursday.
Every game here has a live score, a plain-English read of what people liked and didn't, and the full breakdown: Browse every game's Real Score